| Master | Year |
| *J. Ira Moyse | 1910 |
| *Frank G. Finlayson | 1911 |
| *Enoch A. Troxel | 1912 |
| *Robert J. Burke | 1913 |
| *Charles A. Jones | 1914 |
| *William T. McNeely | 1915 |
| *Reginald W. Clapp | 1916 |
| *Rae C. Van Clevel | 1917 |
| *Arthur Beardsley | 1918 |
| *John J. Stadon | 1919 |
| *William S. Sagar | 1920 |
| *Ira F. Thompson | 1921 |
| *Andrew P. Johnson | 1922 |
| *Thomas H. Dukelow | 1923 |
| *Robert A. Odell | 1924 |
| *Herbert N. Waugh | 1925 |
| *Robert F. Callender | 1926 |
| *Dudley S. Valentine | 1927 |
| *Ronald H. Holbrook | 1928 |
| *Julian F. Grover | 1929 |
| *Fenn M. Durkee | 1930 |
| *Franklin L. Knox | 1931 |
| *John P. Filbert | 1932 |
| *James I. Chilson | 1933 |
| *Henry E. Phister | 1934 |
| *Henry D. Coley | 1935 |
| *Harry L. J. Nicholas | 1936 |
| *Walter B. Stearns | 1937 |
| *Nelson E. Turpin | 1938 |
| *Leon B. Royer | 1939 |
| *Arthur E. Gray | 1940 |
| *Charles C. Ashurst | 1941 |
| *Joseph A. Forest | 1942 |
| *Elbert D. Owen | 1944 |
| *Andy Ruggeri | 1945 |
| *Harry E. Templeton | 1946 |
| *Guy Woolley | 1947 |
| *Orval A. Stevens | 1948 |
| *Fred W. Orgar | 1949 |
| *Roy L. Sawyers | 1950 |
| *Lloyd A. Park | 1951 |
| *George B Danbacher | 1952 |
| *Gordon C. Robinson | 1953 |
| *James M. Hammack | 1954 |
| *Leonard D. Tankersley | 1955 |
| *G. Basil Bates | 1957 |
| *Kenneth E. Hill | 1958 |
| *Arthur L. Holt | 1959 |
| *Clifford Schillinger | 1960 |
| *Anthony V. Radetich | 1961 |
| *Charles K. Schertle | 1962 |
| *Audrey L. Smith | 1963 |
| *Henry A. Taylor | 1964 |
| *William L. Urban | 1965 |
* Deceased
| Master | Year |
| Herbert A. Ronn Jr | 1966 |
| * Maurice S. Reid | 1967 |
| James A. Wiley | 1968 |
| * James W. Watson | 1969 |
| * Frederic H. Mayhew Jr. | 1970 |
| Munson E. Moser | 1971 |
| * Billie R. Dean | 1972 |
| * Hermann W. W. Burmeister | 1973 |
| * Jack G. Sauvain | 1974 |
| + William G. Uhl | 1975 |
| * Robert W. Orr | 1976 |
| * Lorenzo Spain | 1977 |
| * Kenneth C. Sherrow | 1978 |
| + Jose Morales | 1979 |
| Robert H. Petersen | 1980 |
| * Nikola Tschamoff | 1981 |
| * Jack P. Bucci | 1982 |
| * Charles C. Reedy | 1983 |
| Robert H. Petersen | 1984 |
| Raymond G. Kolts | 1985 |
| Victor N. Batarseh | 1986 |
| Carlos Cortez | 1987 |
| * Robert R. Fowler | 1988 |
| Aleksandar M. Piperkov | 1989 |
| Aleksandar M. Piperkov | 1990 |
| * H. William Phares | 1991 |
| Irving Rosenbloom | 1992 |
| Irving Rosenbloom | 1993 |
| + Harvey B. Lyman | 1994 |
| Robert H. Petersen | 1995 |
| Efren V. Garcia | 1996 |
| * Glenden C. Layton | 1997 |
| Efren V. Garcia | 1998 |
| * Carlos H. Gonzalez | 1999 |
| * Alexander B. Birjulin | 2000 |
| Cirilo P. Marquez | 2001 |
| Cirilo P. Marquez | 2002 |
| * Abelardo P. Cabrera | 2003 |
| * Carlos H. Gonzalez | 2004 |
| Irving Rosenbloom | 2005 |
| Edric J. De las Alas | 2006 |
| * Carlos H. Gonzalez | 2007 |
| * Carlos H. Gonzalez | 2008 |
| Irving Rosenbloom | 2009 |
| Cirilo P. Marquez | 2010 |
| Ros G. Paez | 2012 |
| Nolanel M. Yabut Jr | 2013 |
| Ernesto Balba Jr | 2014 |
| Robert D. Petersen | 2015 |
| Irving Rosenbloom | 2016 |
| Daniel Rivera | 2017 |
| Edward Sargsyan | 2018 |
| Smbat Mamyan | 2019 |
| Smbat Mamyan | 2020 |
| Smbat Mamyan | 2021 |
| Haik Hairapetian | 2022 |
| Frank Barbano | 2023 |
* Deceased